Skip to content

What To Do About a Filtered Yelp Review

It’s happened to the best of us. A customer goes on Yelp to leave a review, ends up writing a 5 star masterpiece longer than most Hemmingway novels, and Yelp filters it out. Not only is your business deprived of an awesome review – chances are that your formerly satisfied customer is a little ticked off, too. So what do you do about it?

Filtered Yelp Reviews are Still Reviews

While there are a few different ways to get a review unfiltered, David Mihm brings up an even better idea here:

“I encourage you to republish your filtered Yelp reviews on your own website. There’s no risk of running afoul of any duplicate content issues, since search engines cannot fill out the CAPTCHA forms required to see filtered reviews.”

While the idea overall is phenomenal, the point that filtered Yelp reviews aren’t indexed by Google is off base. To prove it, I took a long string of filtered text from one of My Plumber CA‘s filtered yelp reviews and Googled it. See for yourself:

Filtered review for My Plumber CA in San DiegoFiltered review for plumber in San Diego is indexed by Google

The review may be hidden from the business page, but it’s still clearly visible on the user’s own page. More importantly, it’s still getting indexed by Google.

Why You Should Still Publish Your Filtered Yelp Reviews

While publishing a filtered Yelp review on your own website could hypothetically cause a duplicate content issue, we still think it’s a viable tactic. Let’s start at Google’s official word on duplicate content:

“Duplicate content on a site is not grounds for action on that site unless it appears that the intent of the duplicate content is to be deceptive and manipulate search engine results.”

Republishing filtered reviews definitely isn’t deceptive – they’re still real reviews by real customers – and chances are good that the algorithm won’t punish your site for “stealing” a few lines of content. Otherwise, the above quote, stolen directly from Google itself, would put us in the ground.

More importantly, republishing your customers’ filtered reviews on your own site can play a big role in building relationships with your customers. It’s a proactive way of showing that you really go out of your way to listen to your customers, and that you value their feedback. Plus it can look pretty snazzy on your website:

Garbage disposal repair review on My Plumber CA's website

If you recognize the customer’s name, you should also contact them to thank them and send them a link to where it’s embedded. You can also do it via social media, especially if the customer follows you. Either way, chances are good that taking a moment to spread some good will can get more people talking about your business in a positive light, and it may even earn a couple good links to boot.

A Quick Word of Warning

Besides duplicate content issues, there is still another way that republishing filtered Yelp reviews could backfire.

Although Yelp is pretty public to begin with, not everyone thinks that way. It’s one thing to talk about your personal medical conditions in a yelp review, but it’s another thing entirely to see it suddenly floating around Facebook. Or worse yet, posted front and center on the company’s site.

Depending on the kind of reviews you get, and also the kind of relationships you have with your customers, you may want to consider a little editorial discretion. If you can contact the customer ahead of time, do it. If you don’t recognize the customer, or can’t get in touch with them, you can always edit out the potentially embarrassing parts. A little ellipsis (“…”) goes a long way.

Republished review for Adam Paiso, a chiropractor in Livermore, CA

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *